Ohio’s Rising Utility and Insurance Bills Are a Housing Affordability Challenge

Date:


In particular, affordable housing providers (the landlords who run income-restricted apartments) are seeing this firsthand. In a 2023 testimony to the U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, Columbus-based National Church Residences reported that premiums for the 12 large nonprofit housing providers in the Stewards of Affordable Housing for the Future network had risen 10 to 40 percent year over year in each of the previous three years. They are paying in other ways too. In a 2023 national survey, two-thirds said they had raised their deductibles to manage rising premiums. A higher deductible means the owner pays more out of pocket when a pipe bursts or a storm damages a roof. In the Upper Midwest, some owners report that insurers have stopped covering affordable housing altogether.

Despite the dramatic trends in actual insurance cost escalation, an analysis of budgets included in Low-Income Housing Tax Credit applications to the Ohio Housing Finance Agency (OHFA) shows the continued use of rule of thumb insurance expense assumptions; in applications for the 4 percent tax credit from 2023 to 2026, developers budgeted approximately $600 per apartment per year, with little change in the base year assumption from one year to the next. In other words, Ohio developers appear to be budgeting as if insurance costs are standing still, even as premiums climb for homeowners and apartment owners alike.

Lower long-term operating costs by rewarding efficient, resilient buildings

Strong building standards lower long-term operating costs. Cleveland has required homes that receive its residential tax break to meet the city’s Green Building Standard since 2010, and from 2017 to 2021 alone, the city granted 1,128 tax breaks covering 6,321 homes. Ohio developers have also shown that affordable housing can be built to above-code efficiency and resilience standards: 

  • Fairwood Commons, a 54-unit senior community in Columbus by Woda Cooper Companies and East Columbus Development Company, opened in 2018 as the state’s first multifamily building built to Passive House standards, a very high energy efficiency and resiliency building standard.
  • POAH (Preservation of Affordable Housing), which owns more than 1,000 units of housing in Ohio, has developed new Passive House multifamily properties in the midwest and northeast. While a property built to Passive House may cost 0–3 percent more up front, POAH’s data shows that energy consumption and costs are 63 percent lower for its Passive House properties when compared to code-standard housing in its portfolio for each year for the life of the asset. 

Until this year, OHFA’s design standards have required new affordable tax credit developments to earn a Green Building certification, but its new standards, set to take effect on December 1, 2026, will roll back that requirement, keeping only an energy rating requirement for rehabilitations. This is a step backward for long-term affordability, as the above data clearly demonstrates. As OHFA continues to evolve its requirements, it can look to other states for ideas:

  • Pennsylvania’s housing finance agency began awarding points for Passive House design in 2015. In the first two years, 58 proposed developments planned to meet the standard, and 17 of those were awarded tax credits. Data from the PA Housing Finance Agency shows that the market, developers, builders, and suppliers quickly adapted; in the first year of 2015, Passive House properties were nearly 6 percent more expensive to build. That premium shrunk to less than 2 percent within one year, and reached cost parity with conventional building within three years.
  • Louisiana’s tax credit plan requires storm-resistant FORTIFIED roofs and awards extra points for buildings that go further with resilience measures, such as protecting windows and doors and creating enhanced structural ties.
  • Massachusetts paired bonus points in its tax credit plan with utility incentives, and by mid-2022, 8,500 homes in the state were on track for Passive House certification.

For existing housing, energy efficiency upgrades can avoid a meaningful share of these rising costs. A recent analysis from the Brattle Group illustrates the potential household savings from the efficiency measures commonly included in energy efficiency building standards. It estimated that weatherizing a poorly insulated Columbus home—by adding attic insulation and sealing air leaks—would cut its energy use by about a quarter and lower its bills by about $450 a year. At about $2,000 per home, the upgrade would pay for itself in under five years. For Columbus homes heated with electric resistance heat, Brattle estimated that switching to heat pumps for heating and hot water would save about $1,200 a year, more than covering the $870 gap.

Share post:

Subscribe

Popular

More like this
Related

The Education Exchange: Does School Choice Create School Scarcity?

PAUL PETERSON, HOST: New York City public schools are...

When Red Tape Pulls the Plug on EV Charging

Most people are familiar...

Gentle Bedtime Snacks That Will Not Upset a Sensitive Stomach

The best bedtime snacks for a sensitive stomach...