Struggling readers can consume our minds as teachers. After we’ve given the screener and spent time one on one, when our student is still struggling, we can struggle to know what to do next. What do we do? Today’s show helps us understand how to determine the next step for teaching by helping us know the next step.
Dr. Kay Stahl spent 15 years at the NYU Reading Clinic working with the most severe reading problems. In a three-year longitudinal project, the clinic’s students averaged a year and a half of reading progress in 20 hours of lessons. But that is a dedicated lab? Are there things you can do in a regular classroom?
Kay co-authored Assessment for Reading Instruction, now in its fifth edition. In this episode, she explains how diagnostic assessments work and how they are different from other types of assessments. You will learn how you can know exactly where to focus next in your teaching so it feels more like aiming at the bullseye instead of playing pin the tail on the donkey.
In short: Struggling readers need more than a screener score. A screener tells you whether a child is above, at, or below grade-level expectations. A diagnostic assessment shows which skills the child has and where the process falls apart, so you know what to teach next. Kay’s quick starting point is the Words Their Way spelling inventory.
Jump to the part of the conversation you need most.
Here’s where the facts in this episode come from, with the time stamp so you can hear each one. Checked November 8 and 18, 2026.
This transcript was generated using AI and has been reviewed by humans for accuracy. Minor errors or artifacts may remain but I worked my best to find any issues with the transcript as I reviewed the show. – Vicki
John Davis (00:00): Hello, I’m John Davis. I help produce this show. Today’s show and topic is very important. It’s about how to help kids who are struggling to read and how you can use a diagnostic assessment to show you exactly where to teach next. This is one of the most utilized skills. It’s very important that a child knows how to read and knows how to read well.
This is a Wonderful Classroom Wednesday, episode 1033.
Vicki Davis (00:22): Today’s 10 Minute Teacher is sponsored by Jotform. Turn any paper form, permission slips, exit tickets, hall passes, into an online form in minutes. Learn more at coolcatteacher.com forward slash Jotform.
Announcer (00:39): This is the 10 Minute Teacher Podcast with your host, Vicki Davis.
Vicki Davis (00:43): I’m so excited. Today we’re talking with Dr. Kay Stahl, former clinical professor at New York University and director of NYU Literacy Clinic, and the author of what is one of the most trusted books on reading assessment in American classrooms, Assessment for Reading Instruction. Before she entered academia, Kay taught elementary and middle school for over 25 years and spends her career translating literacy research into practice.
Kay, thanks for coming on the show today.
Kay Stahl (01:19): Thank you so much for inviting me, Vicki. It’s great to be here.
What should I do when a struggling reader is still behind after the screener and small-group help?
Vicki Davis (01:23): Imagine a third grade teacher listening to this on her drive to school and in her class, she has a child who’s struggling to read. She’s given the screener. She’s done the small group. Truthfully, when people start opening a book like yours, it’s because they’ve run out of ideas and they just don’t know what to do.
Kay Stahl (01:40): That is a good place to begin using some diagnostic assessments. And the diagnostic assessments are the best way, in my experience, to pinpoint a child’s learning targets. Because what they really do, the purpose of a diagnostic assessment is to help teachers identify what reading processes the child is undertaking successfully, and what skills and strategies pose a challenge.
So in this way, a teacher can actually build on the child’s strengths and then move into the unfamiliar and difficult.
What does a diagnostic reading assessment tell a teacher that other tests don’t?
Vicki Davis (02:19): So you sent me a slide deck that I reviewed before we had this interview. And I love this quote. You said that without diagnostic assessment, we are playing pin the tail on the donkey with our struggling readers. But that a true diagnostic is like aiming at the bullseye in darts. So unpack that.
Kay Stahl (02:40): I think the kind of tests we’re using a great deal now, especially with the science of reading, is that we see a lot of usage of standardized tests, tests that go along with curriculums, and also our very useful CBMs that are used to monitor children’s progress. And those are all very useful tests. But the reality is they really don’t provide a teacher with the nuts and bolts of what you need to teach next for the child.
But the diagnostic tests will actually help the teacher rather than just trying to do this skill, that skill, like pin the tail on the donkey where I’m blindfolded, just using my curriculum as written. But now it’s enabling me to really look at what the target is based on what a child already knows and what skills we want them to acquire that are next in their developmental trajectory.
What is the difference between a reading screener and a diagnostic assessment?
Vicki Davis (03:37): Okay, so help me understand the difference between a screener and a true diagnostic that works?
Kay Stahl (03:44): So often screeners are done psychometrically by scientists and they know what’s typical for a child in first grade, what’s typical for a child in second grade. They’re dealing with a broad amount of content. And so you’re just getting a range and a score that says, okay, this child is reading above what’s the expectation in second grade. They’re reading below the expectation in second grade or they’re right where second graders are expected to be.
The good diagnostic assessments also have that same psychometric substantiation in terms of validity that you can trust what the test is telling you. However, what these do is really pinpoint particular skills in isolation so then you as the teacher can say, oh, I know that this child knows short vowel sounds, but when the time they get to, maybe spelling a word that has a long vowel, they don’t know whether to put the silent E on the end.
They don’t know whether to spell it with two vowels. A diagnostic test actually tells the teacher, yes, they know this, but now the next step is where the process is falling apart for them. So that is the difference in the two tests. I think it’s important for teachers to recognize that these diagnostic tests, some of them can be done in a group of kids.
Sometimes these tests are a little more intensive because you’re digging more deeply into this individual child. For example, if you’re getting them to read something aloud and then you’re going to be asking them questions and you might be analyzing that to see again, where is the process falling apart? And teachers are busy. And we need things that are time efficient.
How can diagnostic assessments save teachers time?
Kay Stahl (05:36): So I think one of the things that I love about diagnostic tests is they are so time efficient. Instead of experimenting with different things about where the child might be, you’re actually pinpointing through this assessment, they need this particular activity that saves you time in the long run.
How did the NYU Reading Clinic help children with severe reading problems?
Kay Stahl (05:55): So in our NYU Reading Clinic, it was my privilege for 15 years to work in the reading clinic, and it is my heart.
You know, I have my graduate students, and during the spring semester, they tutor in the reading clinic. And so we have children that have the most severe reading problems in the reading clinic. And so our teachers are working with these children after school. They’re exhausted, but we do an hour of tutoring one-on-one twice a week. In the beginning, you know, we did some of those standardized tests that you mentioned.
We also did CBMs to monitor the children’s progress every week or every two weeks. And the children, since they were coming twice a week for one hour over the semester, they got 20 hours of reading instruction. I did a research longitudinal project over three years of the progress of these students. The average was one and a half years of reading progress in 20 hours of lessons.
Vicki Davis (07:06): Wow.
Kay Stahl (07:07): And I do attribute that to the way that we were able to, through diagnostic assessments, really pinpoint where that child needed work, and where they needed to go next and building on what they already knew.
Has the science of reading pushed diagnostic assessments aside?
Kay Stahl (07:23): You know, with the science of reading, it’s wonderful. Teaching reading, we have a lot of research that tells us what works. My worry is because when I’ve been in classrooms, I have seen that teachers are not using as many diagnostic assessments.
And, you know, when you’re changing a curriculum, I know after teaching for 27 years, when you change anything, whether like if I change to a different grade level or if my school is changing the curriculum, what ends up happening is you’re working so hard on what you’re learning new that sometimes some of the old things that you were doing that did work sort of get swept aside in some schools now, that the teachers are working so hard on doing things according to the science of reading that some of these diagnostic assessments are getting left by the wayside.
You know, we want to make sure that we’re not throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
Does diagnostic testing in reading have to be hard?
Vicki Davis (08:20): So what do you wish teachers knew that could ease their burden about using diagnostic testing? Does it have to be hard? Does it have to interrupt everything every day?
Kay Stahl (08:33): We were in an ideal situation in the clinic because, you know, that was our whole mission. That gave us a chance to know and observe. Not every child needs every diagnostic test. And so that’s why you want to discriminate about, for example, older children. One of the battles that teachers that are teaching older children are battling is issues of attitude.
Sometimes they have a bad attitude, you know, about reading or they have attitudes of avoidance. That is a case in where a teacher would say, oh, the diagnostic test that I need to find a few minutes to administer for this child is an attitude inventory. I need to find out what are some of the things that are making this child click?
What are some things that I can do? Are there particular kinds of things that are not just books, but other kinds of reading material like on the computer that they enjoy?
What is a quick diagnostic reading test I can give a struggling reader tomorrow?
Vicki Davis (09:33): Let’s go back to that third grade teacher we talked about at the beginning. She’s got that child who’s struggling. Is there a diagnostic move that she can make tomorrow?
Kay Stahl (09:41): In our book, I call it the quickest, dirtiest test where you can get the most information about a child. And the beauty is this test works from kindergarten up to high school. And that is, I’m going to put a little plug in for the Words Their Way spelling inventory. And that test, it’s very quick to administer. And then you analyze it and you can see the indications of where that child is in terms of developmental stages.
And then you can use that to inform your reading instruction, your phonics instruction, your spelling instruction, and even things like morphology or vocabulary. It gives you cues to those skill sets.
What is morphology, and why does it matter for older readers?
Vicki Davis (10:30): In this fifth edition, you’ve added a whole chapter on morphology.
Kay Stahl (10:34): Yes.
Vicki Davis (10:34): What is morphology? Why did it deserve a chapter in your book?
Kay Stahl (10:39): Okay. Morphology are the separate parts of words. For example, the root words or beginnings of words, prefixes, suffixes that we add to words to make them fit different situations and language situations. And so those are very important because when we talk about children reading and as they get into the upper grades in particular, the words get longer.
They also become more complex because when you add those different prefixes and suffixes to something that is a base word or a root word, then now not only is the child having difficulty reading the word because it’s long, but also there are important cues in those pieces of word that change the meaning of the word. And so if you’re using that in reading in a contextual story or informational text, if you don’t know the proper meaning of that affix, then you’re going to miscomprehend what you’re reading.
So those are very important. I always recommend when I work with middle schools or upper elementaries, your school team of teachers needs to make a list that says, in this grade, we’re going to focus on these roots and affixes. In this grade level, we’re going to focus on these. And then we will have distributed practice when these words are encountered in content area like social studies, science, math.
What encouragement is there for reading teachers who feel unappreciated?
Vicki Davis (12:09): What encouragement do you have for reading teachers?
Kay Stahl (12:12): I have been teaching for 50 years.
Vicki Davis (12:15): Wow.
Kay Stahl (12:16): To me, it is the best job in the world because by teaching somebody to read, you’re really opening the entire world for them. Reading affects so many parts of our lives. Your success in school, it affects the job, it affects how much money you’re going to make in your job. And I just am going to finish this up with this story.
I have in my first or second year of working in the clinic, one of my students, he had a child he was working with in first grade and really a challenge. The child had very low reading level, also very easily distracted. He was wonderful with the child. And then he continued to tutor him also for a couple more years.
I had goosebumps. I was talking to my former student a couple of weeks ago, and he said, Kay, I just want to tell you, guess what? That child that I tutored in the reading clinic is becoming a teacher because of his experience learning how to read with me and with the clinic.
Vicki Davis (13:21): Wow.
Kay Stahl (13:21): And Vicki, that makes every bit of the work worthwhile when you have experiences like that. Yes, the work is hard. Yes, we often feel unappreciated. But guess what? Those kids are watching and listening, and we are shaping the future of our children and our world.
Vicki Davis (13:45): We’ve been talking with Dr. Kay Stahl. Assessment for Reading Instruction is now in its fifth edition. Like there’s all kinds of diagnostics included in the book. Kay, thanks for sharing the story. Today’s episode is sponsored by Jotform. In a recent survey, teachers said that we spend seven hours per week on manual tasks. Jotform can save us time.
First, just describe the form that you need and Jotform AI can build it for you. Exit tickets, quick polls, permission slips. Now, the Jotform Mobile Forms app can turn any tablet by the door into a super fast, low-maintenance hall pass kiosk. And when something needs a signature or approval, Jotform Sign and Jotform Workflows, they can automate the approval process and send it to their right person and cut out all that wasted time spent chasing paper for the approval of forms.
Jotform can be used in a FERPA-compliant way, and on paid plans, your school can sign a data processing agreement. So check with your district before you collect any student data. Teachers are eligible for a 50% discount on Jotform’s single-user paid plans, bronze, silver, or gold. You can start for free at coolcatteacher.com forward slash Jotform. That’s coolcatteacher.com forward slash J-O-T-F-O-R-M.
Thank you, Jotform, for sponsoring today’s show.
Announcer (15:36): Thank you for tuning in to the 10 Minute Teacher Podcast. Join us here every weekday and subscribe to the Classroom Matters newsletter. See you later, educator.
Katherine A. Dougherty Stahl, Ed.D., is a literacy consultant and author who focuses on translating literacy research into practice. Formerly, she was Clinical Professor at New York University, where she taught graduate courses and served as Director of the NYU Literacy Clinic. Before entering academia, she taught in diverse public elementary and middle school classrooms for over 25 years. Dr. Stahl’s scholarship focuses on reading acquisition, comprehension, assessment and intervention. She is the coauthor of several articles and books including Assessment for Reading Instruction (5Ed), Developing Reading Comprehension: Effective Instruction for All Students in PreK-Grade 2, and Reading Assessment in an RTI Framework.
Subscribe so you never miss a Wonderful Classroom Wednesday.
Disclosure of Material Connection: This is a sponsored episode and blog post. Jotform has compensated me to share information about Jotform. However, all opinions expressed are my own. I have personally reviewed these resources and only recommend tools I believe offer genuine value to classroom teachers. My endorsement is limited to the educational products and services discussed in this episode. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.” The sponsor has no impact on the editorial content of this show.


