The international aid sector is enduring such a significant and multi-pronged attack that it is no longer an exaggeration to suggest that we are witnessing the death of the entire system as we know it. As major donors turn their backs on previous commitments, both in terms of concrete financial guarantees and, just as worryingly, in their rhetorical approach to the principles which undergird the international aid system, many of us in the sector find ourselves in a defensive crouch, trying to resist the dismantling of a global architecture for addressing poverty, violence and disaster.
This reality places many of us in an uncomfortable position, especially those of us who for decades have offered a full-throated critique of some of the international aid sector. A great range of opinions, often most convincingly expressed by those ‘beneficiary’ communities at the receiving end of international aid – whether as humanitarian, peacebuilding or development assistance – has defined these concerns. With paternalistic overtones and problematic power relations, which often mirror modes of coloniality that have dominated international relations for centuries, the sector has been guilty for too long of seeing aid as something that rich countries do ‘to’ poor countries (or, in a more charitable interpretation, something they do ‘for’ poor countries). When in truth it should be something that all countries do ‘with’ each other.
For those of us who identify with these critiques, witnessing the total assault on the aid sector can leave us feeling conflicted. Yes, the sector as it previously existed exhibited many problems, but we always wanted to reform it, not abolish it, as this leaves a more fractured, violent and less connected world based on hard power and self-interest.
The aid sector is under attack; arguably, it has been dismantled. Given this context, we argue that the current moment must be assessed for what it is, and our reaction must be authentic and based on the values we have always espoused. It would be disingenuous and hypocritical for us to defend entirely the previous regime of international aid or to argue for its reinstatement exactly as it was.
Instead, what we could do is highlight the genuine and demonstrable achievements of international aid in the previous half century, continue to speak honestly about its shortcomings, and make the case forcefully for the creation of a new system. A new system which is based less on top-down imposition, the exercise of soft power, and overly technocratic administrative systems. We can instead try to imagine a new aid sector built on the fundamental principles of internationalism, solidarity and justice. One in which those actors with means partner with those in need to create sustainable and equitable solutions to global problems.
If this seems overly idealistic or vague, it is only because such generalised language is necessary when discussing an entire system. For more specific examples, it is worth zooming in on specific parts and practices within the world of international aid. Monitoring, Evaluation and Learning (MEL, often alternatively termed M&E, MEAL, DMEL) offers a relevant arena for us to think about this shift. This practice, which involves the ways in which we understand various aid projects, both in terms of their delivery and assessing their merits, has seen rapid growth across the world in recent decades. Guided by the idea of creating better understandings of the context and efficacy of the work we do, it has too often become an added chore and unnecessary burden upon those seeking to do aid work.
Peace Direct, a peacebuilding organisation with networks of practitioners operating in conflict-affected contexts around the world, has spent the last four years examining these practices and thinking about how its commitment to decolonising the sector might shape its thinking on MEL. Through careful and patient conversations with peacebuilders and local organisations, not only did it identify a meaningful critique of the existing models of learning – many felt the data collection and evidence gathering they did for these frameworks were often laborious, of limited use and sometimes used to ‘police’ their activities – but also it started to work towards solutions.
In the development of a decolonial MEL framework, Peace Direct has begun to find ways to co-create methods of learning alongside partners that look quite different. It is led from the bottom-up, with the learning objectives defined by those closest to the context, based on key principles of accessibility and flexibility. These new ideas replace time and labour intensive burdens with more relevant and easy to understand processes. They are aimed at one simple task – answering the questions peacebuilders identify to help them do their work better. This model has not only been developed collaboratively but also been rolled out and used in real life cases.
While the development of this framework does not represent a silver bullet for the sector as some kind of perfectly replicable template for flawless learning processes, it does demonstrate something real about MEL and the sector more widely. It shows that when those of us who are involved in the aid sector are honest about the power imbalances and injustice within the work we have done, and take conscious, concrete steps to acknowledge and address it, we can create new, better and more equitable systems. And when we push back against the violent destruction of the aid sector as a whole, we can do so authentically and comfortably, not defending the status quo, but insisting that we can build it back better.


