What is BAAJA? Your permitting reform questions, answered » Yale Climate Connections

Date:


by Sara Peach, Yale Climate Connections
November 20, 2026

We recently invited Yale Climate Connections readers to ask questions about the divisive Senate permitting reform bill moving through Congress. The result: More emails from readers on this topic than on any other subject in recent memory.  

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or BAAJA, aims to accelerate the permitting process for big energy projects like gas pipelines and wind farms, fulfilling a longtime goal of the clean energy industry. But environmental groups and tribes have fiercely criticized the bill for substantially changing bedrock environmental laws and the federal process for consulting tribes. 

“The bill, the culmination of years of negotiations, is very good for the proponents of many kinds of energy projects (both clean and fossil), especially electricity transmission,” explained Michael Gerrard, founder and faculty director of the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law at Columbia University, in an analysis of the bill. “It is very bad for environmental groups and other project opponents who want to challenge these projects in court.” 

Can proponents give examples of specific good projects needlessly held up? (I can think of plenty of bad projects pending, held up, or canceled.) – Yale Climate Connections reader BS 

Bill sponsor Sen. Martin Heinrich, a Democrat from New Mexico, points to the SunZia wind and transmission project in New Mexico and Arizona. It went online earlier this year – 20 years after it was proposed. Meanwhile, about 400 onshore wind projects are awaiting review by the Pentagon, which doesn’t have enough staff to get through the list, Utility Dive reported last week. 

Supporters of permitting reform have also highlighted a transmission line in Oregon that took 17 years to get a permit. On average, it takes about 10 years to complete a new transmission line project, according to the U.S. Department of Energy. 

Can you explain to us the more specific ways BAAJA weakens current environmental bills and tribal control of sacred lands? This would be very helpful to know to possibly improve the bill as it goes through the amendment process, and what to ask House representatives to amend as they take up the bill. – Reader MH 

Many groups are worried about the ways that BAAJA weakens the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act, the National Historic Preservation Act, and the National Environmental Policy Act, known as NEPA. 

“BAAJA would pull NEPA’s principal teeth – the possibility of a court order blocking a project for violating NEPA,” wrote Michael Gerrard, the Columbia climate law expert. “If there are no serious consequences for violating NEPA, many may come to ignore it. Especially during a hostile administration, agencies might completely disregard NEPA, and everyone will lose the crucial information and public input that it provides.” 

Earthjustice’s team of environmental lawyers put together a detailed guide to the potential implications of the permitting reform bill. See also the team’s analysis of an update to the bill called the manager’s amendment.

Native News Online provides this overview of impacts to tribes: “Tribal Nations and preservation advocates are fiercely opposing the fast-tracked Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) because its permitting reforms – written behind closed doors without tribal input – would strip away vital protections for sacred lands by narrowing required consultations, slashing legal challenge timelines, and preventing courts from halting unlawful energy projects.” 

“It’s thorough and surgical – they knew exactly what they were doing,” one tribal advocate told Native News online. “It was such perfectly engineered legislation designed to strip tribes of their statutory protections that I can’t believe this is happening in 2026.” 

Why does anyone supporting BAAJA as a climate action think that Trump will comply with this? Why does anyone think Trump won’t use BAAJA as a means to expand fossil fuel even more than he is doing now, with less control by law or by the public, and ignore wind and any other renewables? – Reader PH 

We’ve reached out to Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse’s office for comment and will let you know what we hear. Inside Climate News summarized Sen. Heinrich’s argument this way: “the bill cuts permitting for a major power line from about two decades to about five years – still too slow for President Donald Trump to finish much, so the next president collects.” 

Abigail Dillen, president of Earthjustice, disagrees: “Over the next two years, BAAJA would create more legal runway for this president to make corrupt deals and greenlight harmful projects of all kinds, and it would constrain any future president from repairing the damage.”   

I understand a key thing here is urgency: getting clean energy started sooner and lowering costs sooner. My question is: What if we wait for a different bill? Perhaps we could lobby to change this bill or create a new one? – Reader DK 

I want to know if there are alternative pieces of legislation that would accomplish the fast-tracking of renewable energies without trashing existing environmental protections.  Particularly if we just wait a few months for the new Senate and House to be seated. – Reader LR 

Many prominent environmental leaders, including Ayana Elizabeth Johnson, are making a version of this argument: “YES, we need to permit clean energy faster. But, NO, not if that also means permitting dirty fossil energy faster – with major climate justice implications,” Johnson wrote this week. “And another NO if it means undercutting the authority of Tribes and State Governments to protect their water and land.” 

But any future permitting reform bill would need to contend with the filibuster, which requires a 60-vote threshold to advance legislation in the Senate. (In theory, the Democratic majority could change the filibuster rule, but even Sen. Bernie Sanders doesn’t seem to like that idea.) 

Policy veteran Jeff Navin argued (at length) on X and LinkedIn that a clean-energy-only bill would immediately run aground on the shoals of the filibuster. What’s more, Navin noted, many newly elected Democratic Senators support the oil and gas industry. 

“Very few Democrats in the Senate support anything remotely close to a keep-it-in-the-ground agenda,” Navin wrote. “Next Congress, 19 members of the Democratic caucus who voted for cloture on the motion to proceed on this version of the permitting bill will return. They’ll be joined by James Talarico, who has endorsed all-of-the-above and vowed to protect oil and gas jobs. Mary Peltola has explicitly called for more oil and gas development. Scott Colom supports natural gas. Both Adam Hamilton and Annie Andrews endorsed an ‘all of the above’ strategy, which includes oil and gas.” 

I’m following BAAJA closely as I’m worried it will preempt local control over a proposed new compressor station on the Mountain Valley Pipeline in my county in Virginia.  How will it fare in the House if the Senate passes it? Any chance for a veto? – Reader ES  

In politics, anything can happen. But here’s where things stood as of Thursday, November 19, according to The Hill: “While the bill appears highly likely to pass the Senate, its path in the House is a bit less certain. It has bipartisan House support, but it faces some opposition from progressive Democrats. Meanwhile, House Energy and Commerce Chair Brett Guthrie (R-Ky.) has raised pieces of the bill he’d like to change. 

“It is competing with a crowded lame-duck agenda that includes a lapse in federal funding in December if Congress does not act. But the bill has support from the White House, which could help push it through.” 

To what extent can state public utilities commissions balance the bad stuff in this bill?  For example, if a new gas generation facility is proposed but isn’t the cheapest way to add capacity, can they still refuse to allow it?  Can they block a pipeline from serving their state? Can they stop a project if it doesn’t follow state law (for example, the Minnesota clean electricity standard)? – Reader DH  

“BAAJA affects only federal approvals,” said Michael Gerrard, the Columbia climate law expert, by email. “It does not prevent state and local governments from exercising their own authorities. So, for example, if a regulated electric utility receives federal approvals to build a new power plant in federal waters, it would still need approval from the state public utility commission, which would have the ability to disapprove the project.”

This article first appeared on Yale Climate Connections and is republished here under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. 



Share post:

Subscribe

Popular

More like this
Related

Best COP, worst COP? Weary negotiators seek to strengthen outcome 

It’s the last official day of COP and...

Autism Detection Tool Headed To Clinical Trial

SPOKANE, Wash. — Georgina Lynch and Schweitzer Engineering...